NBC Dateline to follow up Outdoor Canada story

In Outdoor Canada magazine’s Winter 2010 issue, we ran an exclusive investigative piece by Charles Wilkins entitled “Another Fine Day Afield.” The 5,000-word article was about the controversial shooting death of American Mark Harshbarger during a 2006 hunting trip to Newfoundland. The Meshoppen, Pennsylvania, man was shot by his wife, Mary Beth Harshbarger, who claims she thought he was a black bear. At the time, our story garnered a lot of attention in Pennsylvania, including a spot on NBC affiliate WBRE Eyewitness News (click here to see the spot).

Early last year, Harshbarger was extradited to Newfoundland where she stood trial for criminal negligence causing death. After two weeks of hearings in September, the presiding judge found her not guilty — this when many believe she is actually guilty of first-degree murder. That’s certainly the viewpoint of Mark Harshbarger’s family, as outlined in the Outdoor Canada feature, which precipitated a Fifth Estate episode that aired on CBC shortly after the trial ended (click here to see the episode).

Now, months later, the mainstream media in the U.S. is again picking up the story: on Friday, NBC Dateline presents “As Darkness Fell,” its examination of Mark Harshbarger’s suspicious shooting death (click here for a preview). Clearly, the notion that there’s more here than meets the eye is gathering steam. Does it mean the case will be reopened? Time will tell.

At any rate, I’m proud that Outdoor Canada first broke this story, and I wouldn’t be surprised if Charles Wilkins picks up a National Magazine Award nomination when they’re announced May 2. He certainly deserves it for his months of dogged investigative work, both in Pennsylvania and Newfoundland, as well as for his great writing. If you’re interested in reading Wilkins’ original, groundbreaking story, please send an e-mail request to

Patrick Walsh

Patrick Walsh

Patrick Walsh is Outdoor Canada's Editor-in-Chief and Brand Manager. He grew up fishing and hunting in Bracebridge, Ontario, where he began his magazine career in 1983 as assistant editor of Muskoka Life magazine. Since then, he has worked for a variety of media, both in Canada and abroad, earning numerous writing and editing awards. In 2005, 2011 and 2012, the Canadian Society of Magazine Editors named him Editor of the Year, while Outdoor Canada was honoured as Magazine of the Year (in the medium circulation category). Walsh has been at the magazine's helm since 2000.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *