Vintage waterfowl decoys: An insider’s guide for collectors and the curious

Advertisement

An eider drake decoy from Newfoundland (photo: Brian Short)

REGIONAL STYLES

If you come across a decoy at your local antique dealer or a garage sale, it’s natural to want to know where it came from and, even more importantly, who might have carved it. However, identifying the place of origin or the individual carver of any particular decoy can pose challenges for the uninitiated.

The fact is, carving styles are highly varied, influenced by several factors: the type of hunting the decoy was designed for (field or water set-ups); the type of water being hunted (open lakes, rivers, marshes or salt water); the species being hunted; the traditional decoy style of the region it came from; and the preferred style of the carver.

Advertisement

Considering those influences, knowledgeable collectors can usually identify a decoy’s region of origin, Short says. Here are the various styles he’s identified from different regions of Canada.

THE MARITIMES

Carvers here mostly created decoys for their own use, rather than for sale. Typically, the blocks are oversized and somewhat crude, with few details. And in order to stand up to the constant exposure to harsh salt water, the use of house paint is the norm. Commonly carved species include mergansers, loons, goldeneyes, eiders, scoters, long-tailed ducks and both Canada and Brant geese.

Advertisement

Detailed carving typifies decoys from Quebec (photo: Brian Short)

QUEBEC

There are several radically different carving styles in Quebec, particularly along the length of the St. Lawrence River. A frequently common trait of decoys from here, however, is the rather intricate and detailed carving on the wings and back. Among the most commonly carved species are goldeneye, bluebills, canvasbacks and black ducks.

Sleek goldeneye decoys from Eastern Ontario (photo: Copley Fine Art Auctions)

ONTARIO

Ontario is undoubtedly home to the most carvers and decoys, with many collectors breaking the province into three distinct regions: Kingston and east; the Greater Toronto Area; and southwestern Ontario. While there are subtle variations in each region’s decoys, Short says, they aren’t completely different. Commonly carved waterfowl include mallards, black ducks, goldeneye, canvasbacks and bluebills, although decoys of virtually every huntable species can be found.

When compared with their counterparts down East, Short says, decoys from Ontario tend to have sleeker, smoother, more gentle profiles, with few back or wing details. That’s because Ontario’s typically sheltered hunting waters didn’t demand the same chunky decoys needed for the rough waters of the Maritimes or along the St. Lawrence. The exception, perhaps, are Lake St. Clair region decoys, which are usually more substantial for better visibility at a distance.

A Ducharme decoy from  Manitoba (photo: Brian Short)

THE PRAIRIES

Not many decoys have originated from Saskatchewan or Alberta, despite the region being the breadbasket of North American waterfowl production. That’s because waterfowl hunting wasn’t particularly popular among the few people who lived in the region back in the day. Instead, much of the duck hunting was practised by visiting hunters, most of whom brought their own blocks. Even as duck and goose hunting grew in popularity among local residents, it generally took place on small potholes or in fields, neither of which required large numbers of decoys. As one noted collector observes, “The better the hunting, the worse the decoys.”

Manitoba, on the other hand, spawned several carvers of note, thanks in large measure to the waterfowl-rich marshes associated with Lakes Winnipeg, Manitoba and Winnipegosis. Of particular renown are the decoys from Lake Winnipeg’s Delta Marsh (see “The Delta decoys”).

BC’s decoys were made to ride high on the water (photo: Brian Short)

B.C.

Relatively isolated from the influence of eastern Canadian carvers, B.C.’s decoy carvers developed a style to meet their own unique needs. Most waterfowling there took place on big water, either on or adjacent to the ocean, so the decoys were designed to ride high on the water, remaining visible as they rose and fell with the swells. The conditions also required the decoys to be rigged with substantial anchors, as well as heavy ballast weights so they’d self-right if tipped over. To help offset their large size, the decoys were also commonly hollow-bodied.

Despite the plethora of waterfowl species found along the West Coast, many were considered undesirable by hunters. As a result, most of the province’s decoys were made to replicate snow geese, brant, mallards, pintails and wigeon.

Photo: Brian Short

THE DELTA DECOYS

Any discussion of Delta Marsh’s legacy of waterfowl decoys needs to start with General Mills founder James Ford Bell, who also established the renowned Delta Waterfowl Research Station. An avid waterfowler, Bell was lured to Delta Marsh on the south end of Lake Manitoba in the early 1920s by the promise of canvasbacks. That was after the canvasback population on his home water, Heron Lake in southwestern Minnesota, declined due to overhunting and habitat change.

Bell enjoyed the gunning at Delta so much he bought land there and built a hunting lodge. Over time, the decoy rig he’d brought from Heron Lake began to show its age and needed replacements, so he turned to his lodge manager, Ed Ward, for help. For that, Ward commissioned two locals, “Little Joe” Ducharme and his brother, Dan. Little Joe made several modifications to improve on the horsehead style of the Heron Lake decoys, adding the rounded cheeky head, long thin bill and sharply sloped neckline—changes that define what’s known today as the “Delta style” of decoys.

Over time, the Ducharme brothers proved too slow for Bell’s liking, however, so he began building the body blanks at his mill in Minneapolis. He’d then send those to Ward, who in turn commissioned Little Joe, Dan and Little Joe’s son, Duncan, to carve the heads and do the painting. Duncan was a gifted craftsman in his own right, and at some point in the 1930s, Ward had him take over from his father to make most of the replacement decoys.

With solid bodies carved from white cedar and heads from white pine, Duncan’s sturdy decoys were able to withstand the rigours of regular hunting use; they featured the steeply angled, pointed breasts and large keels that now help define a Ducharme decoy. Interestingly, many of Duncan’s decoys were actually painted by Peter Ward, Ed’s son, over the years. Peter was a noted waterfowl artist in his own right, and served at one time as a director of the Delta Waterfowl and Wetland Research Station.

Today, Duncan Ducharme is recognized as the most prolific of the Delta Marsh decoy carvers. He made thousands up into the 1960s, with his customers extending beyond Bell. In the 1950s, for example, he carved a rig of redheads for Robert Gaylord, an American industrialist and lodge owner on Manitoba’s Lake Winnipegosis. Today, the classic lines of Ducharme’s Delta Marsh decoys are a favourite among modern collectors. Many are identifiable by the stamp on the bottom, reading “Duncan Ducharme, Decoy Maker, St. Ambroise, Manitoba.”

Dan Ducharme, meanwhile, made comparatively few decoys, but developed his own style, featuring a deeper body than those of his Delta Marsh counterparts, complete with bob-tails and large heads. Many informed collectors consider his decoys to be the finest of the Ducharme blocks.