Against all odds, the huge shark was lip-hooked
Against all odds, the huge shark was lip-hooked

Fishing the Keys: Sweat, blood, slime, blender drinks and shark attacks

Advertisement

On my third and final day in Key West, I head out on a beautifully rigged 31-foot Mako belonging to Columbia Sportswear pro staffer George Poveromo (above). A Florida legend and host of the nationally televised George Poveromo’s World of Saltwater Fishing, he’s taking us for mutton snappers at a reef area known as the Dry Rocks.

Advertisement

Under grey skies, we anchor in 80 feet, and set out bottom rigs consisting of a three-way swivel with a 15-foot leader and a 7/0 circle hook baited with a six-inch long live pinfish, and a heavy weight. Averaging 15 pounds, mutton snappers are big and strong, so we’re using rods as thick as broomsticks. We immediately have a few takes, but can’t convert.

A trophy-size yellowtail snapper—big fun on light tackle (Photo: Glenn Law)

Yellowtail snapper

Meanwhile, Poveromo also tethers a frozen block of chum to the stern, where the eight-knot current creates a chum line. He gives me a medium-weight outfit and shows me how to “flatline.” Using a 1/0 circle hook, a credit card-sized slice of dead bait and no weight, I just open the bail on the spinning reel and let line out in a controlled drift through the chum slick. With about 100 feet of line out, I feel a small bump, start reeling, and the circle hook does its work. It’s a 20-inch yellowtail snapper—trophy size for this species—and a nice fight on the light gear. I decide I like flatlining.

 

Advertisement

George Poveromo expertly gaffs a nice dorado (left); and poses with Columbia Sportswear’s Krystl Tonkin.
George Poveromo expertly gaffs a nice dorado (left); and poses with Columbia Sportswear’s Krystl Tonkin.

Dorado (full-grown)

More excitement ensues when Poveromo spots a nice dorado cruising near the boat. He grabs a spare mutton rod, tosses the bait right on the fish’s snout, and it takes. George passes the rod to Tonkin, and after a short, frantic, battle she gets it to the side of the boat where Poveromo gaffs it beautifully, like a viper striking a mouse.